PEACEFUL PIANO MOODS
Deutsche Grammophon
486 0288 9 / 4 CDs
I am not one for compilation CDs, simply because they tend to be brainless and clueless when it comes to programming choices, something like Singapore’s so-called classical radio station. These usually pander to the lowest common denominator, and the listener is left none the wiser. One of the worst compilations involved Universal Music and Popular Bookstore years ago, when one thought they should know better.
Peaceful Piano Moods is a four-disc compilation of quiet mood music, solo piano selections supposed to soothe the soul and calm the nerves. It comes from the vast back catalogue of Deutsche Grammophon and some newer recordings issued not in albums but for streaming and downloads but including here. There are 103 tracks in total, of which 59 (57.3%) are actually classical music, from J.S.Bach to John Cage. At worst, these represent musical wallpaper, best heard as muzak or elevator music in lounges too cheap to hire an actual pianist. At best, there are individual tracks by some of classical music’s greatest artists to enjoy, but all submerged within swathes of sound.
The four discs are named according to the times of day, Morning, Afternoon, Evening and Night, and the pieces chosen more or less (usually less) conform to this. In another classification, the music is sub-themed The Eternal Piano (presumably the classics), The Infinite Piano (minimalist music, who knows?) and The Celluloid Piano (music from the movies). There are more tracks than I care to name that belong to the mind-numbing New Age, minimalist, quasi-spiritual, spa-friendly categories which can easily be generated by AI (artificial intelligence) nowadays, and are pretty much easily forgotten and thus disposable.
 |
| Lilya Zilberstein & Vikingur Olafsson |
So what are the classical tracks worth listening to? Disc 1 (Morning) has two selections by Russian pianist Lilya Zilberstein who is excellent in Brahms’ Intermezzo in E flat major (Op.117 No.1) and Rachmaninov’s Prelude in G major (Op.32 No.5). Icelandic phenom Vikingur Olafsson’s transcription of Rameau’s Entree de Polymnie from Les Boreades called The Arts and The Hours is worth listening to, equal to the great baroque transcriptions of Busoni and Kempff. The great French duo of Katia & Marielle Labeque contributes the Berceuse from Gabriel Faure’s Dolly Suite. Just to name drop, there are also tracks from Martha Argerich (Schumann’s Traumerei), Daniel Barenboim (Liszt’s Consolation No.3), the late Tamas Vasary (Debussy’s Arabesque No.1) and Alfred Brendel (just one variation from Beethoven’s Eroica Variations)
 |
The Kontarskys also perform a few of Brahms' Waltzes Op.39 |
Disc 2 (Afternoon) has the box’s longest track in Debussy’s Prelude a l’apres-midi dun faune in its two-piano guise from the German duo of Alfons and Aloys Kontarsky. Another duo is Mary Howe’s arrangement of Bach’s Sheep May Safely Graze, played by Lucas and Arthur Jusson. There are almost 9 minutes of Gershwin, Someone To Watch Over Me from Andre Previn and Love Walked In from Chinese pianist Moye Chen. Mozart’s most famous sonata movement, in C major (from K.545) is heard from Maria Joao Pires, no less. A surprise is to hear Beethoven’s little Minuet in G (a popular children’s piece) from Mikhail Pletnev. Shorts by classical piano’s hotshot youngsters – Yuja Wang, Behzod Abduraimov, Alice Sarah Ott, Seong-Jin Cho and Jan Lisiecki – may also be found here. A particular favourite of mine is Sergei Babayan playing Rachmaninov’s Lilacs. Clearly the best disc of the four.
 |
Andrei Gavrilov gets the most playing time of all the pianists. |
Disc 3 (Evening) includes many Russian and Slavic pianists of distinction. Care to name them? What about Andrei Gavrilov (Grieg’s Summer Evening, Schubert’s Impromptu in G flat major and the Aria from Bach’s Goldberg Variations), Lazar Berman (Rachmaninov’s Moment Musicaux No.5), Anatol Ugorsky (Beethoven’s Fur Elise and Chopin’s Largo in E flat), Ivo Pogorelich (Scarlatti’s Sonata “Pastorale” K.9 and one of Mussorgsky’s Promenades from Pictures at an Exhibition) and Zoltan Kocsis (Debussy’s Page d’Album). The best tracks are Shura Cherkassky playing the Saint-Saens-Godowsky The Swan and Martha Argerich and Nicolas Economou in Tchaikovsky’s Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy.
 |
We should have had more Chopin Nocturnes from Maria Joao Pires! |
Disc 4 (Night) begins promisingly but ends in disappointment. A disc that opens with Maria Joao Pires playing Chopin’s C sharp minor Nocturne (Lento con grande espressione) and Yuja Wang playing the Gluck-Sgambati Dance of the Blessed Spirits should never include mindless slop that passes as mood music by Max Richter, unless one is in dire need of a tranquiliser. Elsewhere, Francesco Tristano plays John Cage’s In A Landscape and Alice Sara Ott plays Grieg’s Solveig’s Song.
 |
Francesco Tristano in a landscape (sans gravity). |
 |
| Va-va-voom Van-Ahn |
There are world premiere recordings by Chad Lawson and Van-Ahn Nguyen, with the Australian-Vietnamese pianist playing film music tracks including from The Sound of Music, Sense and Sensibility, The English Patient and Missing. All very charming. One personal rant: I cannot tolerate artists who graffitise classical pieces by adding ambient sounds and noise, throw in a few string textures and claim these to be personal treatments of music they love. There are two such tracks that have degraded Chopin and Satie. How very pretentious.
All in all, at budget price, one can find gems among the dross. If this helps you sleep better, Peaceful Piano Moods certainly beats paying a doctor to prescribe you sleeping pills. And probably a lot cheaper too.